A well-maintained brick and ivory ranch on a broad autumn lawn, with part of a taller newer Colonial visible next door in a quiet Paramus neighborhood.

How Paramus Teardowns Set the Price of an Original Ranch

In the week of August 31 to September 6, 2026, three houses on Spring Valley Road in Paramus changed hands. Number 366 sold for $750,000, number 537 for $1,545,000 and number 228 for $2,300,000, according to NJ.com's weekly Bergen County property transfer roundup. That is one road, one week and a gap of more than $1.5 million.

The cheapest of the three is a 1954 house with 1,912 square feet of interior space, according to the public tax record on NJParcels. The current assessment there is $573,900. Land accounts for $301,700 of it and the house for $272,200. By the assessor's numbers, the ground under that house is worth more than the house.

That split explains most of the Paramus market. A buyer who looks at an original ranch, Cape or split-level in this borough is bidding against two kinds of buyers. One wants to live in the house. The other wants the lot. The state's own construction records show how often the second buyer wins.

Paramus led the county in 2025

The New Jersey Department of Community Affairs publishes monthly counts of demolitions and new housing units for New Jersey municipalities. Its December 2025 year-to-date report shows that Paramus demolished 55 one- and two-family units in 2025, more than any other town in Bergen County.

Bergen County town 1–2 family units demolished, 2025 1–2 family units authorized, 2025
Paramus 55 88
Lyndhurst 54 10
Tenafly 29 30
Cliffside Park 26 26
Fort Lee 24 70
Cresskill 18 15
River Edge 5 9
Glen Rock 1 14
Fair Lawn 1 0
Saddle River 0 6

The table is drawn from the DCA's December 2025 demolition report and December 2025 new-housing report. Paramus also authorized 88 new one- and two-family units in 2025. Among the towns at the top of the demolition list, only Lodi authorized more, with 533.

The towns lower in the table make the comparison clear. Fair Lawn and Glen Rock each recorded a single demolition in 2025, and River Edge recorded five. In those towns an older house mostly sells to someone who will live in it or renovate it. In Paramus, about one sale in four, measured against the borough's roughly 200 single-family closings a year, can end with an excavator on the lot. That ratio is approximate, because DCA counts units and the closing count comes from MLS data.

This has been the pattern for four years

A single year can be a fluke. Paramus's numbers come back at the same level year after year. In the DCA December year-to-date reports, the borough recorded these one- and two-family figures:

Year Units demolished Units authorized
2022 41 38
2023 57 74
2024 52 43
2025 55 88

That adds up to 205 one- and two-family units demolished from 2022 through 2025, and 243 authorized. The 2022, 2023 and 2024 demolition reports are all public.

The reason is the age of the housing. About two-thirds of Paramus's single-family homes were built between 1945 and 1975, mostly as ranches, Capes, split-levels and bi-levels. Many of those houses sit on lots that builders want. Each year a steady share of them goes to a builder. The rest sell at a price the builder's offer helps set.

The cheaper house is priced against the lot

The split in Paramus prices tracks the age of the house more than the street it sits on. From January 1 through October 2, 2026, NJMLS data showed existing Paramus homes selling at a median of $993,750 across 130 sales. New construction sold at a median of $2,340,000 across 30 sales. That puts new construction at close to one closing in five this year, and its median runs more than double the median for the older homes.

The two groups also move at different speeds. On October 2, 2026, Paramus had 46 active single-family listings. The 11 listed under $1 million represented about 1.3 months of supply. The 18 listed at $2 million and above represented about 5.1 months. The older, cheaper houses are scarce partly because builders buy some of them before an owner-occupant gets the chance. The finished new houses at the top of the market have more competition from one another and take longer to sell.

A single address shows the same thing. Public records list 260 Virginia Court with a 2024 build year, 3,723 square feet and a $1.82 million deed recorded on May 27, 2025. The builder, New Jersey General Contractors & Builders, describes the house on its project page as 2024–2025 new construction with six bedrooms, about 4,000 square feet above grade and a finished 2,000-square-foot basement, and advertised it at $2.2 million. The borough's older housing has a long run of houses like that ahead of it.

The fall 2026 transfer roundups show the same spread across the borough. NJ.com's lists for late summer and early fall include 63 Nichols Drive at $800,000, 193 Homestead Road at $850,000, 309 South Drive at $1,465,000, 71 Andrea Court at $1,552,000 and 50 Hemlock Drive at $1,585,000. The Sept. 7 to 13 roundup adds 90 Arnot Place at $775,000 and 28 Skye Drive at $1,420,000. The weekly lists record title transfers, which can lag the actual sale date.

2026 is running at about the same pace

The DCA's official 2026 monthly reports run only through January so far. That month shows six one- and two-family units demolished in Paramus and six authorized. For more recent months there is the state's raw construction permit file on data.nj.gov. It holds 54 Paramus demolition permit records and 47 new-construction permit records dated 2026, the latest from late July and early August. The DCA describes that file as unaudited permit data, so it is not a count of housing units. At that pace, 2026 permit activity is roughly in line with 2025.

The county market around Paramus is cooling slightly while prices keep rising. New Jersey REALTORS' October 2026 report for Bergen County, current as of November 9, shows a single-family median sale price of $880,000, up from $805,000 in October 2025. Inventory rose to 1,166 homes from 1,008, months of supply rose to 2.8 from 2.3, and sellers received 102.0% of list price, compared with 102.6% a year earlier. Those are countywide figures. Paramus's older-house segment had less supply than the county average on October 2, and that gap fits the idea that builders are part of the demand for those houses.

What this means for a buyer comparing towns

A buyer who wants an original Paramus house to live in, renovate or expand is bidding against builders, who have their own math. The builder works back from a finished price above $2 million. That puts a floor under lots that a buyer from Fair Lawn or Glen Rock would not see at home. When an older Paramus house looks expensive next to a similar house one town over, the extra cost is usually the lot.

For sellers of an original postwar house in Paramus, the buyer pool includes builders as well as families, and those two groups judge the same house in different ways. A family looks at the kitchen and the roof. A builder looks at frontage, depth and what the lot can hold. The same age that draws builders also raises due-diligence questions for any buyer, and our post on oil tanks in Paramus homes built before 1975 covers one of the most common. If you are weighing a finished new house in Paramus instead, our guide to Paramus new construction picks up from there.

The numbers favor Paramus for buyers who start with land. Over four years, the borough has replaced about 50 houses a year with new ones, and its median for new construction this year is more than double the median for existing homes. The Paramus neighborhood page has more on how the borough's streets differ.

If you own one of Paramus's original ranches, Capes or split-levels and want to know what it is worth to a family and to a builder, Christian Di Stasio Group can walk you through how both kinds of buyers are likely to see it. Schedule a white‑glove consultation, or start with a home valuation.

Work With Us

We bring together a mix of integrity, imagination and an inexhaustible work ethic, striving to make each buying and selling experience the best possible.

Follow Us on Instagram